Evaluation

 2008-2009 GHP Annual Evaluation Report

The 2008-09 GHP annual report was created by GHP evaluators, Celia Makin-Bell and Nicky Adamson and includes a summary of GHP events in 2008-9 and detailed qualitative and quantitative information regarding current GHP activity.  It also highlights core strengths and areas of added value and upcoming opportunities and priorities throughout the next financial year and contains information about all forthcoming evaluative practices leading up to December 2009.

 A few key findings from the report are:

 2008-9 Local Authority subscriptions funded 32% of GHP delivery costs and 12% of total spend in relation to GHP and its projects, a figure that reduces to 2% if the subsequent HLF and BIG awards are taken into account.

GHP and its partners have accessed external funding for project delivery from a range of non-arts partners in 2008-09. The work of GHP and its partners released additional funding of £2M for the Town Centre Gardens project from HLF and £1.4M from BIG for South Oxhey.

GHP has achieved a range of national and local media coverage during 2008-9. GHP was showcased on an international stage in Northern Ireland and will be showcased in Copenhagen as part of the 2009 UN Climate Change Conference, COP15 and the United Nations Habitat World Urban Forum.  It was also the view of a consultee that “word has traveled positively” about the impact of GHP across the Herts Local Authorities and voluntary sector.

In July 2005, the GHP Steering Group appointed independent evaluators Hall Aitken to carry out an external assessment of the partnership.

Since then, the evaluators have carried out desk research, mind-mapping workshops with the steering group, online questionnaires and interviews with project leads, artists and stakeholders.

Following the agreement by all the Hertfordshire Local Authorities to continue subscribing to GHP for a further three years, Hall Aitken were asked to continue to evaluate the partnership during that time.

Summary of Reports

Interim Evaluation Report -
Published in November 2006, this report assesses the strengths and weaknesses of the partnership and identifies opportunities for future development.

The report gives an overview of the GHP approach and outlines the projects to date. It goes on to look at GHP’s successes in engaging communities in the development of open space, high quality and sustainable design, developing expertise and skills, changing the perception of the role of artists and levering in external funding.

Although comparison between other projects is difficult because of the lack of similar projects, the report tries to identify how GHP compares with one similar authority.

The report recognises that there are a number of opportunities to widen the scope of the partnership. It also identifies opportunities for the approach to become self-sustaining in the future, for example through Section 106 agreements.

Stevenage Case Study
In 2007, Hall Aitken produced a case study exploring the work GHP had been doing with Stevenage Borough Council across two projects. The resulting report looks at the impacts of the GHP approach on Stevenage and the possibilities of replicating this in other areas. It identifies one of the legacies of GHP's involvements as i

ncreasing the levels of community participation from around 20 to 200 people. It also concluded that GHP excelled in bringing disparate departments and colleagues together for the purpose of pushing a project through.